WFSVs – fatigue, safety and manning levels

This article has been adapted from a paper given at the Royal Institution of Naval Architects’ International Conference on Wind Farm Support Vessels. It is reproduced with permission.

Offshore windfarms can be busy sites, crowded with obstacles
Offshore windfarms can be busy sites, crowded with obstacles

TUV SUD PMSS has recently highlighted concerns with regard to Wind Farm Support Vessel (WFSV) operations in a paper presented at a Royal Institute of Naval Architects (RINA) conference on WFSV design and in a presentation at a Renewables-UK Conference.

The intent was to highlight our concern that manning levels and, hence, hours of work and watchkeeping are not compliant with regulatory requirements and guidance.

WFSVs usually operate with a crew of two or perhaps three personnel, only one of whom is a qualified bridge watchkeeper. Similar manning levels apply to some of the most recent vessels intended for unrestricted operations in the North Sea and not just vessels within the MCA Small Commercial Vessel Code.

The normal working day is of 14 hours in order to meet the requirements of STCW 95 and The Merchant Shipping (Safe Manning, Hours of Work and Watchkeeping) Regulations 1997 and The Merchant Shipping (Hours of Work) Regulations 2002. That is, that a minimum 10 hours rest is required in every 24 hour period. However, this interpretation is only a partial application of the Regulations and ignores the requirements for watchkeepers. The 1997 Regulations require that the watchkeeping arrangements for the ship are adequate for maintaining safe navigational watches having regard to Chapter VIII of section A of the STCW Code. This requires that “the company shall, for the purpose of preventing fatigue:

• establish and enforce rest periods for watchkeeping personnel; and,

• requires that watch systems are so arranged that the efficiency of all watchkeeping personnel is not impaired by fatigue

Regulation 9 of the 1997 Regulations requires a Schedule to be produced which specifies the hours of work for those whose work includes regular watchkeeping duties or ship handling;so that they do not work more hours than is safe in relation to the safety of the ship and the performance of their duties. This schedule shall specify the maximum period of continuous watchkeeping and the minimum rest period between watches.

In addition, the Regulations require that, in establishing manning levels, consideration should be given to how the crew will deal with various emergency situations.

The MCA’s Marine Guidance Note (MGN) 315 on “Keeping a Safe Navigational Watch” states that fatigue, the weather and any additional duties and unusual demands on the OOW are to be taken into account when composing a bridge watch.

The Regulations, whilst allowing for personnel to be at work for 14 hours, intend that watchkeeping duties are not undertaken continuously but that the OOW -or lookout – has periods of watchkeeping interspersed with rest periods. That the person who has charge of a high-speed craft with passengers is on watch continuously for 14 hours is not only contrary to the regulations but opposed to normal maritime best practice where fatigue has been recognised as a major issue. Would a bus driver be permitted to drive for 14 hours without rest? Would any other commercial vessel Captain be expected to be at the helm of his/her vessel for 14 hours?

The remedies lie in the hands of the vessel operators who specify the vessel manning requirements to the vessel designer and also in the hands of the regulators who need to look closely at, not just compliance with Codes, but at the application of the Regulations which are there to ensure that manning levels are, as required by the MCA, “sufficient to ensure the safe and efficient operation of the ship at all times”. Of course, it is also a matter for the windfarm developers and operators to ensure that their operations are conducted in a manner consistent with the Regulations, Guidance and best practice.