‘Wind Power – Beyond the Bluster’ published

A report examining the true effectiveness of wind power technology has been published, revealing interesting evidence and facts that call into question many of the myths often associated with this growing sector of the renewable energy industry.

Despite the often negative comments about wind energy, investors clearly make different assessments. Photo: Peter Barker
Despite the often negative comments about wind energy, investors clearly make different assessments. Photo: Peter Barker

Produced by the UK think tank Institute for Public Policy Research together with renewable energy consultants GL Garrad Hassan, the document, with the relevant title ‘Beyond the Bluster – why wind power is an effective technology’,addresses two basic yet relevant questions: is windpower an effective way of reducing carbon emissions? And, is wind power a secure and reliable energy source? While offshore wind is more expensive that onshore, costs with the former are coming down, with the same basic conclusions applying to both.

The report points out that the views of those affected by wind turbine developments in their area, both onshore and offshore, should be properly considered, but equal consideration should be given to the views of wider public opinion which consistently and strongly supports wind power. While UK government support for wind power together with costs for the end-user are constantly scrutinised, the reader is reminded that from 2004 to 2010, government support for renewables added £30 to the average energy bill while rises in the wholesale cost of gas added £290.

Claims that wind power is unpredictable are described as “inaccurate”. As wind forecasting improves across the whole electricity system (more accurately than individual site forecasts), the aggregate of forecasts of wind power output across larger geographical areas will be markedly more accurate over time, indeed being as variable and predictable as demand.

Addressing wind power output stability, the report finds that the rate of output change is similar to the changes in demand from power users. Examination of an extreme weather event in Ireland in 2011 (where wind capacity is a far larger proportion of the total than in GB) found that the ‘long, cold, calm spell’ risk was easily dealt with without compromising system security, this particular risk being described as overstated. The UK National Grid reports that up 30GW of wind power can be accommodated and the report adds that numerous technological options such as improved interconnection and intelligent management of supply and demand through a smart grid are available to improve this piece of the jigsaw.

The report concludes that wind power energy is a potent way of reducing carbon emissions without threatening energy security and with little impact on the existing operation of the grid, even extending significantly beyond the levels of low-carbon generation technologies that are expected in the UK.

Space does not allow a fuller review of this report but it is a document that clearly demands wide consideration by those engaging in the debate about wind power. As the title states, it goes beyond the bluster.

By Peter Barker