It follows a far-reaching court decision that found a subcontractor responsible for a failure in the design of a windfarm, despite following an industry standard.
The case heard earlier this year involved MT Højgaard’s work on the transition piece grouting of the Robin Rigg array for energy provider E.On. It was carried out to accepted DNV criteria only later found to contain an error: unfortunately this resulted in a tower lifetime of just a couple of years, far short of the agreed two decades. “The cost of remedial work to the turbines on the Robin Rigg wind farm in the Solway Firth was £26.25m,” said Baldev Bhinder of law firm Ashurst. But who was to bear responsibility?
MT Højgaard argued, unsuccessfully, that it carried out works “to the (flawed) industry standard” which meant it shouldn’t be held responsible for the final “fitness of purpose”. The judge however found that: “It is not uncommon for … contracts to contain obligations both to exercise reasonable care… and to achieve a particular result.”
Although the case has excited a huge amount of sympathy, the appeal (due in spring 2015) may well not reverse the decision because the subcontractor, like many involved in windfarm construction, took on the energy developer’s requirement for a 20 year design life instead of negotiating the kind of ‘reasonable skill and care’ clause that’s more common to the general construction industry.
Mr Bhinder underlined that “increased risk associated with this higher standard should be priced accordingly”. However, although contractors may well need to put up prices “quantifying this amount will not be easy” and he added contractors “will be wise to look into their insurance coverage for such situations”.
There are a few strings to pull to shape the contracts. Mr Bhinder went on to say: “Where pricing proves to be a stumbling block, contractors may seek to limit overall liability or attempt to expressly qualify the fitness for purpose warranty to a lower standard.” He added that some parties may attempt some “creative drafting” to qualify the warranty up to a certain identifiable standard, but pointed out: “Naturally, such attempts can be tricky and might lead to more doubt than clarity.”
So, despite obvious pressures to give guarantees, Mr Bhinder concluded: “Ultimately, parties should approach fitness for purpose clauses with caution and the clear knowledge as to its impact.”
By Stevie Knight