Windfarm development: is it worth the risk?
For most, the aftermath of WWI and WWII is a thing of the past, but for European windfarm developers, it could be more of an everyday risk.
Across Europe, most countries have a common heritage in terms of unexploded ordnance (UXO) threats offshore, as a result of war mines, munitions dumps and sunken ships from World War One (WWI) and World War Two (WWII).
While the threat posed by UXO in the North Sea has been well documented to a certain extent, Simon Cooke, director of 6 Alpha Associates, a specialist risk advisor managing this threat, told Maritime Journal, it’s still very much a problem when it comes to offshore development, particularly windfarm development.
“Sea mines from WWI in UK waters are only found once every 10 years, but that just shows the longevity of the issue. Many more naval mines have been left from WWII and not all were recovered. Anywhere between 30 – 70% were recovered, so they crop up much more frequently,” Mr Cooke explained.
In Europe, munitions have been dumped in France, Germany, Holland and other countries. This is also true in the USA, and vessels have been sunk,
With offshore renewable energy projects involving turbine installation and cable laying, this UXO could easily be detonated and result in injured crew, sunken vessels
Activities like installing monopiles using a jack-up vessel, cable laying with a cable plough, or dropping anchors from anchor handling tugs, could be “catastrophic”, but this can be easily avoided with a desk study, Mr Cooke told MJ.
“The key to windfarms, or any offshore development, is to consider what activities are going to be undertaken and what munitions could be there. A desk study based on
The company has worked on 45 different renewable energy projects where there has been some level of UXO contamination and has provided UXO consultancy on 45% of UK Round 1 projects, 73% of Round 2 projects, and 78% of Round 3 projects, as well as a significant number of French and German developments.
Most recently, it worked on the Gwynt y Môr site in Wales, where three bombs were found during turbine installation. Vessels were kept off site and an exclusion zone was set up until the bombs could be dealt with, which took a few weeks just to gain permission.
To help developers avoid UXO, 6 Alpha has developed a five-stage risk management framework which advises on
“By thinking ahead and planning in advance,
6 Alpha Associates delivers consultancy as well as end-to-end project management services globally.
By Rachael Doyle
A rare opportunity has arisen to join us as Harbour Master for the busy and thriving Harbour at Ilfr... Read more
This is a high profile, challenging and rewarding job at the heart of BFSAI in the Falkland Islands. Read more
A successful marine consultancy is currently looking for enthusiastic and experienced people to join... Read more
We are looking for an experienced Multimedia Designer to join a busy Marketing Department based in F... Read more